I traced the letters on scrapbook paper and cut them out, then painted the edges of the wooden letters. J and Y are red, and the O is green. The great thing about this is that if you get the paint on the front of the letters, its not a big deal, its covered by the paper!
Glue the paper letters to the top of the wooded letters.
With a glue gun, I glued the letters on and on the left is an angel ornament I picked up at Michael's. I wanted it to be simple and clean, and I am really happy with how it turned out.